Re: 5.3-RELEASE TODO

From: Emanuel Strobl <Emanuel.Strobl_at_gmx.net>
Date: Sat, 30 Oct 2004 23:46:16 +0200
Am Freitag, 29. Oktober 2004 09:41 schrieb Scott Long:
> This is an automated weekly mailing of the FreeBSD 5.3 open issues list.
> The live version of this list is available at:
>
>     http://www.FreeBSD.org/releases/5.3R/todo.html
>
> Automated mailing of this list will continue through the release of
> FreeBSD 5.3
>
>
>                           FreeBSD 5.3 Open Issues
>
>                                 Open Issues
>
>  This is a list of open issues that need to be resolved for FreeBSD 5.3. If
>  you have any updates for this list, please e-mail re_at_FreeBSD.org.
>
> Issues that require investigation
>
>  +------------------------------------------------------------------------+
>
>  | Issue |   Status    | Responsible |            Description             |
>  |-------+-------------+-------------+------------------------------------|
>  |
>  |       |             |             | More 'wedging' problems have been  |
>  |       |             |             | reported with specific if_em       |
>  |       |             |             | hardware. The hardware found in    |
>  |
>  | if_em | In progress | Bruce M.    | the IBM T-41 seems to be a         |
>  | wedge |             | Simpson     | suspect. Removing ALTQ support     |
>  |
>  |       |             |             | from the driver might help this    |
>  |       |             |             | problem, but reports are           |
>  |       |             |             | inconsistent.                      |
>
>  +------------------------------------------------------------------------+
>
> Show stopper defects for 5.3-RELEASE
>
>  +------------------------------------------------------------------------+
>
>  |     Issue      |   Status    |  Responsible   |      Description       |
>  |----------------+-------------+----------------+------------------------|
>  |
>  |                |             |                | Attaching GDB to a     |
>  |                |             |                | threaded process will  |
>  |                |             |                | leave the process in   |
>  |                |             |                | an unkillable state.   |
>  |                |             |                | Rebooting the machine  |
>  |
>  | Threaded       |             |                | is the only way to     |
>  | application    |             |                | recover from this.     |
>  | get stuck in   |             |                | This is easily         |
>  | an unkillable  | In progress | David Xu       | triggered when a KDE   |
>  | state when     |             |                | app crashes and KDE    |
>  | touched by GDB |             |                | automatically attaches |
>  |
>  |                |             |                | GDB to it to extract a |
>  |                |             |                | stack trace. A         |
>  |                |             |                | candidate fix is in    |
>  |                |             |                | 6-CURRENT. More        |
>  |                |             |                | testing and review is  |
>  |                |             |                | needed.                |
>  |
>  |----------------+-------------+----------------+------------------------|
>  |
>  |                |             |                | There have been        |
>  |                |             |                | reports that, under    |
>  |                |             |                | extremely high load,   |
>  |                |             |                | the tcp_output()       |
>  |                |             |                | routine may appear to  |
>  |                |             |                | run for extended       |
>  |                |             |                | periods, resulting in  |
>  |                |             |                | the appearance of a    |
>  |                |             |                | hang for an extended   |
>  |                |             |                | period (up to 30       |
>  |
>  | Reports of     |             |                | minutes), followed by  |
>  | TCP-related    |             |                | recovery. This may be  |
>  | instability    |             | George V.      | a result of a bug in   |
>  | under          |             | Neville-Neil,  | the TCP selective      |
>  | extremely high | In progress | Robert Watson, | acknowledgement        |
>  | load; possibly |             | Scott Long     | implementation         |
>  | related to     |             |                | introduced following   |
>  | SACK           |             |                | 5.2; the release       |
>  |
>  |                |             |                | engineering team is    |
>  |                |             |                | currently working with |
>  |                |             |                | the submitters to      |
>  |                |             |                | diagnose the problem.  |
>  |                |             |                | Depending on the       |
>  |                |             |                | nature of the problem, |
>  |                |             |                | it may be appropriate  |
>  |                |             |                | to release with SACK   |
>  |                |             |                | disabled, or to        |
>  |                |             |                | correct the bug prior  |
>  |                |             |                | to 5.3.                |
>
>  +------------------------------------------------------------------------+
>

Showstoppers:

What about misc/72895, i386/73251 and misc/72896? The latter is not that 
critical but GEOM_GPT really has edges on i386 which aren't suitable for 
-stable! Removing GEOM_GPT from GENERIC would be one solution IMO, fixing of 
course was even better, but I can't help.
And then there's kern/71355 which has been closed without any improovement. 
The opposite: I can confirm that this also applies to the sil3114 chipset 
when the BIOS (of the PCI Card (Dawicontrol DC-154))) is enabled (so booting 
from it is possible) and two drives are set up as mirror!

-Harry

Received on Sat Oct 30 2004 - 19:46:21 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Wed May 19 2021 - 11:38:20 UTC