I reran the 12-concurrent tarball extraction with adaptive giant enabled/disabled, on the 12-processor e4500: real time: x adaptive-giant + no-adaptive-giant +--------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | x + x | | + x + + x | | x + xx *x ++ xx+ + | | x + ** ** *+ xx*+ + + | | x x+ **+** ** *x**** * * +x + | | x x x x+x*****************x*x* +x+ * + | |x xxx **+x*x*********************x+x* * ++++ + + +x + +| | |________A_________| | | |_________M_A__________| | +--------------------------------------------------------------------------+ N Min Max Median Avg Stddev x 100 77.48 89.74 82.17 82.2382 2.2768285 + 99 79.02 94.62 82.77 83.29596 2.6837291 Difference at 95.0% confidence 1.05776 +/- 0.691261 1.28621% +/- 0.840559% (Student's t, pooled s = 2.48758) system time: x adaptive-giant + no-adaptive-giant +--------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | +x | | x +x + | | x x xxx* x +* + | | xx x+ xx** * +* + + + | | xx x* x***x * ** ++ x+** + + + | | x xxxx*x+x******x****++*+** +++++ x ++ | |x x x x*xx****x**x******************* *++**++***+*+ *+ + +| | |_________MA__________| | | |__________MA___________| | +--------------------------------------------------------------------------+ N Min Max Median Avg Stddev x 100 428.87 515.95 468.41 469.8407 15.138894 + 99 448.08 528.59 478.97 480.89152 15.913392 Difference at 95.0% confidence 11.0508 +/- 4.31528 2.35203% +/- 0.918455% (Student's t, pooled s = 15.529) user time x adaptive-giant + no-adaptive-giant +--------------------------------------------------------------------------+ | xx + | | x xx + + | | x xxx *x *x *++ + +++ | | xx +xxx xx*+*x+**+*++ +* x *+++ | | x xx*x+xx*+*+*x***x******* **+* *++++ + | |x+ x * + +x* xx*x*x***********************+*+**+*++xx x+ +x+ +| | |___________A__________| | | |____________A___________| | +--------------------------------------------------------------------------+ N Min Max Median Avg Stddev x 100 27.66 28.96 28.35 28.3449 0.22686932 + 99 27.67 29.1 28.47 28.459899 0.24268269 Difference at 95.0% confidence 0.114999 +/- 0.0652666 0.405713% +/- 0.230259% (Student's t, pooled s = 0.234869) So adaptive giant is in fact a small net win in all 3 measurements. I'm not sure whether my previous measurements with generic build were incorrect or have some other explanation. Kris
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Wed May 19 2021 - 11:38:34 UTC