Wilko Bulte wrote: > On Sat, Apr 07, 2007 at 12:54:57PM +0200, Jorn Argelo wrote.. >> Rich Teer wrote: >>> This is fantastic news! At the risk of raking over ye olde arguments, >>> as the old saying goes: "Dual licensing? We don't need no stinkeen >>> dual licensing!". :-) >>> >>> >> First of all, thanks a lot for all the hard work of both the FreeBSD >> developers as the ZFS developers. I can't wait to give it a go. >> >> That leads me to one question though: Why is *BSD able to bring it into >> the OS as where Linux has licensing problems with the CDDL? AFAIK Linux >> users can only run it in userland mode and not in kernel mode because of >> the licenses. > > My guess(!) is that they do not want non-GPL-ed code in the standard kernel. Sorry if I'm reiterating what someone maybe already explained, but I don't see it on the lists I read: FreeBSD can include GPL'ed code due to a "technicality" (literally): As long as the code is in a separate kernel module and not in the default shipped GENERIC kernel, it's considered "bundled" and not a part of the kernel. As soon as the user loads a GPLed kernel module, presto-changeo! his kernel "automagically" becomes GPLed. I believe the same holds for CDDL. (I have no idea how to resolve the licensing issues of a kernel with both GPL and CDDL parts :) ). This is less inconvenient than it seems since kernel modules can be (pre)loaded at the same time the kernel loads, and so we can have a ZFS root partition, etc. The problem with DTrace in FreeBSD is twofold: 1. It's much more intertwined with the kernel. 2. Much of its usability comes from it being available in the default shipped kernel - so that users can use it to troubleshoot problems "on the fly" without having to recompile and install a new kernel (involves rebooting). AFAIK (not involved with its development), most of dtrace can reside in a kernel module but some parts need to be in the kernel proper to support this mode of operation, and *this* is where the licensing comes in. Just a few files (AFAIK: mostly header files!) need to be dual-licensed so they can be included in the default kernel build, and the rest can be in the CDDL licensed kernel module.
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Wed May 19 2021 - 11:39:08 UTC