On Tue, 2008-02-26 at 14:35 -0800, Julian Elischer wrote: > Peter Jeremy wrote: > > IMHO, it would > > be reasonable to get input from re_at_ as to whether they would like > > the stack left alone for a while to simplify the resolution of any > > issues that may crop up once 7.0 is released. > > I agree that we need to wait for 7.0 but 7 and 8 are already > diverging, and the whole point of the 7 branch is to isolate 7 from > -current. From the re_at_ point of view I'd like to see this go in about a month from now. You are exactly right that it would be good to get it in early on in what becomes the 8.0 release cycle. But it's in Perforce so it's visible to interested parties who want to look it over and have a chance to kibitz before it gets into CVS, and now that you've given the heads-up (thanks!!!!) people who think they might have a stake in this know to go do that. I know the 7.0 release cycle dragged on way way too long (and I've apologized for that as much as I can...) but there is a period of time after the release that we appreciate people not doing stuff that's too drastic to ease any potential "emergency work" needed as people start using the release. That's the point of the week grace period after the release that re_at_ holds on to ownership of the branch before turning it over to sec-team_at_. And we know for a fact we've got some stuff already surfacing that's likely to need Errata Notices. You've pointed out 7 and 8 are already diverging and given how long the release cycle took I can't get too mad at people who have already made significant changes but I'd still prefer it if they hadn't happened quite yet. If you think the month thing is too long I really can't stop you, but this summarizes the feelings as re_at_... It's a balance between not disturbing things too much in case "stuff comes up" related to 7.0 and getting some major and promising work into the tree early in the release cycle for 8.0. Hopefully having it in Perforce between now and then doesn't cause too much inconvenience. -- Ken Smith - From there to here, from here to | kensmith_at_cse.buffalo.edu there, funny things are everywhere. | - Theodore Geisel |
This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0 : Wed May 19 2021 - 11:39:28 UTC