Re: nfe problem on 8.0-BETA2

Pyun YongHyeon wrote:
> On Thu, Aug 20, 2009 at 02:07:39PM -0400, Travis Mikalson wrote:
>> Pyun YongHyeon wrote:
>>> On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 07:56:05PM -0700, Ryan Rogers wrote:
>>>> Pyun YongHyeon wrote:
>>>>> On Wed, Jul 22, 2009 at 03:26:43PM -0700, Ryan Rogers wrote:
>>>>>> Weongyo Jeong wrote:
>>>>>>> On Wed, Jul 22, 2009 at 05:26:07AM -0500, Sam Fourman Jr. wrote:
>>>>>>>>> svn co svn://svn.freebsd.org/base/head
>>>>>>>>> svn merge -c -193289
>>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>>> Thereafter, in the root of the repo:
>>>>>>>>> svn up
>>>>>>>>> svn merge
>>>>>>>> Confirmed, running the above set of commands fixed my 88E1116 nfe 
>>>>>>>> problem
>>>>>>>> everything works as it should now. thanks guys for the help.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> Sam Fourman Jr.
>>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>> ps. svn was WAY faster than csup, I think I am going to use svn all
>>>>>>>> the time now.
>>>>>>> I know that yongari_at_ knows what the problem is and the solution but he
>>>>>>> could not access the internet right now due to relocation to USA.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> It looks he is busy with looking for house and etc...
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> regards,
>>>>>>> Weongyo Jeong
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>> Well, the good news is that r193289 was the only thing keeping my nics 
>>>>> >from working.  I was able to update to current as of today and revert 
>>>>>> that patch, and everything is working nicely now.  So I'll just keep my 
>>>>>> eye on the commit logs and patch that up by hand whenever I need to 
>>>>>> update until yongari is able to get situated.
>>>>>>
>>>>> Would you try attached patch and let me know how it goes on your
>>>>> box?
>>>> The patch works great, thanks!
>>> Thanks for testing.
>>> Unfortunately the change requires more testing on various
>>> controllers. 88E1116 PHY is commonly found on Yukon Ultra or newer
>>> Yukon controllers as well as NVIDIA controllers. Since we are in
>>> 8.0-BETA stage changing common PHY code at this time looks
>>> dangerous.
>> Before I start a bug report, I'm curious, do you think it is possible
>> for this issue to also affect the general stability in operation of the
>> nfe driver? I mean if nfe comes up and works fine for many days and then
>> suddenly stops passing traffic?
>>
>> In both 8.0 and 7.2-STABLE some time after the beginning of June, two
>> separate systems with two different nfe NICs started showing exactly the
>> same issue. The 7.2-STABLE system was built from June 16th source and
>> has a Marvell 88E1116. The 8.0-BETA2 system has a Marvell 88E1111 and is
>> built from Aug 13th source. Both systems did not ever have this issue
>> with code from before June (7.2-RELEASE included).
>>
> 
> Sorry, I don't know. Both Marvell, vendor of PHY hardware and NIVIA
> , vendor of ethernet controller didn't release documentation to
> open source developers, so some part of code might be wrong on some
> controllers. I think nfe(4) didn't have code changes during that
> time window. e1000phy(4) received a couple changes to support LED
> for Yukon FE+, Yukon Ultra and Yukon Extrme. But I don't think it
> may cause problems on nfe(4) as the change only affects LED
> blinking rate. You can verify it by backing out r193291.
> 
>> Both will stop passing traffic across their nfe0 NIC randomly and
>> require an ifconfig nfe0 down; ifconfig nfe0 up to continue. In the
>> meantime before the interface is reset, ping says sendto no buffer space
>> available and named starts spitting out a lot of "error sending
>> response: not enough free resources" from the DNS queries it was in the
>> middle of responding to.
> 
> By chance are you using jumbo frame? Before digging into source
> code it would be even better to know which controllers you have.
> Just sending dmesg(1) output related with nfe(4)/e1000phy(4) would
> be enough to know that.

I updated my system to RELENG_7 source from last night
and tried out your patch, it hasn't had any effect on my nfe problem I'm
afraid. A few hours after rebooting my nfe interface started dying and
requiring a reset again.


So, that answers that question. I definitely have a separate unrelated
issue from the one in this thread.