Re: patch: let msdosfs(vfat)/ntfs to support UTF-8 locale well

On Thu, 12 Feb 2009 20:34:40 +0200
Gleb Kurtsou <gleb.kurtsou_at_gmail.com> wrote:

> On (10/02/2009 17:12), 裴国兴 wrote:
> > I write a patch to support UTF-8 locale well. I think it maybe help
> > for some FreeBSD user.
> > follow link is the patch (base on FreeBSD 7.1):
> > http://btload.googlegroups.com/web/msdosfs.patch?gda=MzIscT8AAABs_gmy4a1S9lRiXjEy-V5OpwtI67JnIGlz0zr18tjObOtoi5oIt3BJMRGeqGBbbj-ccyFKn-rNKC-d1pM_IdV0
> > the full tar.bz2 package:
> > http://btload.googlegroups.com/web/msdosfs.tar.bz2?gda=IG1pBkEAAABs_gmy4a1S9lRiXjEy-V5OpwtI67JnIGlz0zr18tjObNLRc95Ps2S1UISaL0WhuitTCT_pCLcFTwcI3Sro5jAzlXFeCn-cdYleF-vtiGpWAA
> > 
> > I also will patch for ntfs driver
> > http://btload.googlegroups.com/web/ntfs.patch?gda=OqsHoDwAAABs_gmy4a1S9lRiXjEy-V5O7RN7t-m4MjZ-5dQn_EvaqDVCWO9_HyYEQJyRQYPtRCL9Wm-ajmzVoAFUlE7c_fAt
> > http://btload.googlegroups.com/web/ntfs.tar.bz2?gda=zErXED4AAABs_gmy4a1S9lRiXjEy-V5O7RN7t-m4MjZ-5dQn_EvaqG3K0t6fVz8SMYStF_2dqCPjsKXVs-X7bdXZc5buSfmx
> > 
> > The Chinese characters in the fat32 partition can be displayed correctly now.
> > 
> > when mount windows partitions, you should do like this:
> > mount_ntfs -C UTF-8 /dev/ad?s? /path/to/mount
> > mount_msdosfs -L zh_CN.UTF-8 /dev/ad?s? /path/to/mount
> 
> I've also looked at it recently but my idea was to update kiconv to
> handle ucs-2 (or whatever it is) -> utf-8 conversion in kernel. kiconv
> supports different translation methods. Current implementation just
> creates a table for ucs2->utf-8 conversion and passes it too kernel. It
> seems it can't even handle all of unicode chars.
> Fixing kiconv would be a better solution, imho.


Some people attempted to improve kinconv and locale on filesystems.
I only remember this one at this moment; http://people.freebsd.org/~imura/kiconv/
This work was never merged into the tree excpet few bug fixes to other reasons.
This was back in 5.x relases.  So, it doesn't apply cleanly these days.

I also seens some people posted similar patches to the list in past years.
However, none of them got any attentions to the project.

I think we somehow have to get enough attensions of some (reasonable number
of people) FreeBSD committers to this.  Otherwise, people keep reinvening
and posting patches to this topic.

Regards,
Hiro